Skip to content

Carriage service to menace, harass or offend: section 474.17.

Abusive calls, threatening texts and offensive posts or messages can be charged under Commonwealth law. The case is heard in a NSW court, but Commonwealth rules decide where it can be dealt with and how it is sentenced.

Excellent · 119 Google reviews (as at November 2026)

Office hours Monday to Friday, 9am to 5pm. Urgent or after hours? Call 0404 791 111 or connect via WhatsApp.Can't talk now?

Portrait of Bash Elkheir

Bash Elkheir

Partner

View profile
Portrait of Bashir Elkheir

Bashir Elkheir

Criminal defence · Senior Associate

View profile

Client feedback · Google reviews

A few words from our criminal law clients.

“I had an excellent experience with Bash and his team. They gave me very clear, honest and professional advice from day one and delivered as promised. I was facing very serious charges with life changing consequences however Bash and his …”
H HGoogle review excerpt · Criminal law
“I can’t thank Bashir El Kheir and the team at Cordoba Legal enough. I was facing serious charges and looking at doing time, but Bashir fought hard for me and got an outstanding result with no conviction recorded. …”
Albion StoreGoogle review excerpt · Criminal law

The law, explained

General information. Maximum penalties are for the most serious cases, and the outcome depends on the facts and your record.

Part 1 of 5

The law

What does section 474.17 of the Criminal Code say?

Section 474.17(1) of the Criminal Code Act 1995 (Cth) (opens in a new tab) makes it an offence to use a carriage service in a way, whether by the method of use or the content of a communication, or both, that reasonable persons would regard as being, in all the circumstances, menacing, harassing or offensive. The maximum penalty is 5 years' imprisonment.

The section expressly covers menacing, harassing or offending emergency call takers and some other public call takers.

What is a carriage service?

A carriage service is a service that carries communications electronically. Phone calls, text messages, emails, social media posts, direct messages and video calls all use one. The offence can be committed by the way you use the service, such as repeated calls at night, or by what you send.

Is this a Commonwealth or a NSW offence?

It is a Commonwealth offence, heard in NSW courts when the conduct happens here. NSW has its own offences that can overlap, such as stalking or intimidation under section 13 of the Crimes (Domestic and Personal Violence) Act 2007 (opens in a new tab). Depending on the facts, police may charge one or both.

Part 2 of 5

What must be proved and the maximum penalty

What must the prosecution prove for using a carriage service to menace, harass or offend?

  • You used a carriage service, such as a phone, messaging app, email or social media.
  • Reasonable persons would regard the way you used it, through the method, the content or both, as menacing, harassing or offensive in all the circumstances.
  • The fault elements: where an offence does not specify them, section 5.6 of the Criminal Code (opens in a new tab) requires intention for conduct and recklessness for a circumstance or result.

Each element must be proved beyond reasonable doubt.

How is menacing, harassing or offensive judged?

Objectively: the question is what reasonable persons would think in all the circumstances, including the context and what came before. In deciding whether material, or a use of a carriage service, is offensive, section 473.4 of the Criminal Code (opens in a new tab) lists matters including the standards of morality, decency and propriety generally accepted by reasonable adults, any literary, artistic or educational merit, and the general character of the material.

What is the maximum penalty for section 474.17?

5 years' imprisonment. Because the maximum is more than 12 months, it is an indictable offence (section 4G of the Crimes Act 1914 (Cth) (opens in a new tab)). Under section 4J of the Crimes Act 1914 (Cth) (opens in a new tab), it can be dealt with in the Local Court if the prosecutor and you both consent. The Local Court can then impose up to 12 months' imprisonment, a fine of up to 60 penalty units, or both.

Part 3 of 5

Court, likely outcomes and your record

Which court hears a section 474.17 charge?

The charge starts in the Local Court. It stays there if the prosecutor and you both consent to it being dealt with summarily. Otherwise it is dealt with on indictment in the District Court, where the full 5-year maximum applies.

How are Commonwealth offences sentenced?

Under the Crimes Act 1914 (Cth) (opens in a new tab). Section 16A requires a sentence of a severity appropriate in all the circumstances of the offence, and lists matters the court must take into account where relevant, including the nature and circumstances of the offence, any injury, loss or damage, any victim impact statement, contrition, a guilty plea and its timing, and cooperation with law enforcement.

Can I avoid a conviction for a Commonwealth offence?

Possibly. Section 19B of the Crimes Act 1914 (Cth) (opens in a new tab) is the Commonwealth equivalent of a NSW section 10 order. If the charge is proved, the court can dismiss it, or discharge you without conviction on condition that you are of good behaviour for up to 3 years. The court considers your character, antecedents, age, health or mental condition, how trivial the offence was, and any extenuating circumstances.

Part 4 of 5

Defences

What are the defences to a section 474.17 charge?

  • Reasonable persons would not regard the use as menacing, harassing or offensive in all the circumstances. Rude, angry or robust communication is not automatically enough.
  • Identity: someone else sent the messages or used the account. Shared devices, hacked accounts and fake profiles can raise a doubt.
  • Context: the full conversation, not selected screenshots, may show how the messages would be understood.
  • Fault: the prosecution must prove the fault elements, for example that you meant to make the call or send the message.

Part 5 of 5

First steps

What should I do after a carriage service charge?

  • Stop all contact with the person, including through friends or other accounts, and comply with any bail conditions or AVO.
  • Do not delete messages, posts or accounts. Keep the whole conversation, including messages you received.
  • Get advice before a police interview, especially about who had access to your phone or accounts.
  • Ask early about a section 19B outcome, so references and other material can be prepared.

Recent results

Recent criminal law results.

Outcomes for clients of our Sydney criminal defence lawyers in the Local, District and Supreme Courts of NSW, including charges withdrawn, not-guilty verdicts, bail and sentences served in the community. Newest first, from October 2026 back to July 2023.

Showing: October 2026, Unlawfully seized iPhone returned after our letter to NSW Police

Police powers · Seized property

Unlawfully seized iPhone returned after our letter to NSW Police

Phone returned · No data extracted · No court case needed

NSW Police seized our client's iPhone after a traffic stop, suspecting it held information that could assist a criminal investigation. Police search and seizure powers in NSW come mainly from the Law Enforcement (Powers and Responsibilities) Act 2002 (NSW) (opens in a new tab), and police can use them only in the circumstances the law allows. Our criminal defence lawyers examined how the phone had been seized and concluded that the seizure was improper and unlawful. After we wrote to NSW Police, the phone was returned to our client immediately, and no data had been extracted from it. The matter was resolved without any court proceedings.

Domestic violence · Charges withdrawn

Domestic violence charges and ADVO withdrawn at Burwood Local Court

All charges and the ADVO withdrawn · Clean record kept

Our client faced a number of domestic violence charges involving an immediate family member, along with an application for an apprehended domestic violence order (ADVO). We were engaged a month before the hearing and started work straight away, preparing the defence case and a strategy to show that the allegations were false. On the hearing day at Burwood Local Court, we persuaded NSW Police to withdraw all charges and the ADVO application. Under section 12 of the Crimes (Domestic and Personal Violence) Act 2007 (NSW) (opens in a new tab), a guilty plea or finding on a domestic violence charge is recorded on a criminal record as a domestic violence offence. With every charge withdrawn, our client kept his clean criminal record.

Firearms Prohibition Order · Seized property

Court orders return of a phone seized in a Firearms Prohibition Order search

Local Court orders the phone's immediate return

NSW Police seized our client's mobile phone following a bail compliance check and a Firearms Prohibition Order (FPO) search. Section 74A of the Firearms Act 1996 (NSW) (opens in a new tab) lets police search a person subject to an FPO, and premises and vehicles they occupy or control, for firearms, firearm parts and ammunition. Our criminal defence lawyers concluded that seizing the phone went beyond the powers available to police, but police refused to return it. After a defended hearing in the Local Court of NSW and detailed cross-examination of the officer in charge, the Local Court judge accepted our interpretation of the law and ordered that the phone be returned to our client immediately.

Fireworks · Charge withdrawn

Fireworks charge withdrawn at Inverell after we challenged the phone search

Charge withdrawn on the hearing day · Plea offer declined

Our client, a young adult, was charged over videos of fireworks that NSW Police found on his phone while executing a search warrant. Police offered to accept a guilty plea to a less serious charge. On our advice, our client rejected the offer and wanted his day in court. While reviewing the brief of evidence, our solicitors identified issues with the legality of the search and seizure of his phone, and impropriety in how police obtained the videos. Evidence obtained improperly or illegally can be excluded under section 138 of the Evidence Act 1995 (NSW) (opens in a new tab). On the day of the hearing at Inverell Local Court, the prosecutor accepted our representations and withdrew the charge.

Murder · Charge withdrawn

Murder charge dropped: client released after more than a year in custody

Murder charge withdrawn · Released from custody

Our client was charged with murder and had spent more than a year in custody after being refused bail. Elkheir Partners' Sydney criminal defence lawyers analysed the brief of evidence and identified insufficient evidence to support the murder charge. Following our representations to the prosecution, the charge was withdrawn at an early stage of the proceedings, and our client was released from custody immediately.

Firearms & weapons · Domestic violence

Serious charges withdrawn in Parramatta firearms and weapons case

Community Correction Order · No prison sentence · Immediate release

Our client faced multiple serious domestic violence charges involving the alleged use of a firearm and a knife, as well as firearm and weapons possession, intimidation, assault occasioning actual bodily harm (ABH) and possession of steroids. After carefully reviewing the brief of evidence and identifying weaknesses in the prosecution case, our criminal defence lawyers advised our client to contest the charges at a hearing. On the hearing day in Parramatta in June 2026, we negotiated a plea agreement involving the withdrawal of the most serious charges, the downgrading of other charges and favourable agreed facts. Following our sentencing submissions, the court imposed a Community Correction Order (CCO), allowing our client's immediate release from custody without a prison sentence. A CCO is a non-custodial sentence served in the community under conditions; it does record a conviction.

Drug supply · Sentencing

Intensive Correction Order, not full-time jail, for 2 kg ice supply

Intensive Correction Order · No full-time custody

Our client pleaded guilty to supplying 2 kilograms of methamphetamine (ice), a large commercial quantity. He was released on bail after three weeks in custody. Following thorough preparation and detailed sentencing submissions by our criminal defence lawyers, the court imposed an Intensive Correction Order (ICO): a sentence of imprisonment served in the community under conditions, rather than in full-time custody. Our client returned home.

Drug importation · Charges withdrawn

Imported drug and aggravated break and enter charges dropped

Bail granted · Charges withdrawn

Our clients were charged with serious offences, including attempting to possess imported border-controlled drugs, a Commonwealth drug offence, and aggravated break and enter. From the time of their arrest, our lawyers challenged the strength of the prosecution case. Each client was granted bail in the Local Court of NSW, and following detailed negotiations with the prosecution, the charges against each client were withdrawn.

GBH · Sentencing

No jail for a grievous bodily harm (GBH) charge: Community Correction Order

Community Correction Order · No prison sentence

Our client was charged with recklessly causing grievous bodily harm (GBH), affray and other serious offences. Our criminal defence lawyers negotiated to narrow the agreed facts and resolved the case with a guilty plea to a single charge. Following detailed submissions in mitigation, the court imposed a Community Correction Order (CCO), which is served in the community rather than in jail.

Wounding with intent · Jury trial

Not guilty: jury acquits client of wounding with intent to cause GBH

Jury verdict: not guilty

Our client was charged with wounding with intent to cause grievous bodily harm (GBH), which carries a maximum penalty of 25 years' imprisonment under section 33 of the Crimes Act 1900 (NSW) (opens in a new tab). The prosecution alleged he was part of a joint criminal enterprise, which can make each person who agrees to commit a crime responsible for what the others do to carry it out. Our lawyers prepared his defence case in detail and identified issues with the complainant's credibility. Following a jury trial in Sydney, our client was found not guilty.

Cybercrime · Jury trial

Not guilty on all seven Commonwealth computer hacking charges

Jury verdict: not guilty on all charges

Our client was charged with seven Commonwealth cybercrime offences, alleging the development and online sale of malicious software, after a joint investigation by the Australian Federal Police (AFP), the FBI and the Royal Canadian Mounted Police. It was the first time this type of offence had been prosecuted at trial in Australia. The four-week trial in the District Court of NSW involved extensive expert evidence, complex legal issues and software that was no longer available for defence testing. After one day of deliberations, the jury found our client not guilty of all charges.

Drug manufacture · Sentencing

No full-time jail on a large commercial drug manufacturing charge

Intensive Correction Order · Minor role accepted

Our client was charged with manufacturing a large commercial quantity of a prohibited drug, an offence with a maximum penalty of life imprisonment. After extensive negotiations, the Crown accepted that our client had played a minor role in the drug manufacturing syndicate. At sentence, the judge accepted our submissions and imposed an Intensive Correction Order (ICO), so our client went home rather than to jail.

Criminal appeals · Domestic violence

Domestic violence sentence reduced on appeal: immediate release from custody

Sentence reduced · Released from custody

Our client had been sentenced to a substantial term of imprisonment for multiple domestic violence and arson offences. Our criminal defence lawyers appealed the sentence to the District Court of NSW. The appeal succeeded, and the reduced sentence allowed our client's immediate release from custody.

Assault · Defended hearing

Not guilty of assault occasioning actual bodily harm in company at Inverell

Found not guilty after a defended hearing

Our client was charged with assault occasioning actual bodily harm (ABH) in company, which carries up to 7 years' imprisonment under section 59(2) of the Crimes Act 1900 (NSW) (opens in a new tab). The alleged injuries required hospital treatment, and the Director of Public Prosecutions prosecuted the case in Inverell Local Court. Our client maintained his innocence. We made a successful tendency application about the complainant, meeting the notice and significant probative value requirements of section 97 of the Evidence Act 1995 (NSW) (opens in a new tab), then undermined his credibility and reliability in cross-examination. The court found the charge had not been proven, and our client was acquitted.

Police pursuit · Defended hearing

Not guilty of a Skye's Law police pursuit charge: identity not proven

Found not guilty · Identity not proven

Our client was charged over a motorcycle police pursuit in which the rider evaded police. Failing to stop for police and then driving dangerously is an offence under section 51B of the Crimes Act 1900 (NSW) (opens in a new tab), carrying up to 3 years' imprisonment for a first offence. To prove our client was the rider, police relied on circumstantial evidence, including a similar tattoo and his brother's nomination of him in response to a police Form of Demand. Our lawyers cross-examined the officer in charge closely about the improper way the case was investigated and the evidence obtained. After the defended hearing in Sydney, the court found the prosecution evidence was insufficient to prove our client was the rider.

Drug importation · Sentencing

Six-year non-parole period for importing 67.7 kg of ice

Non-parole period of six years · Principal role rejected

Our client faced 35 charges, including drug importation, firearm offences and $1.5 million in proceeds of crime. The most serious was importing almost 68 kilograms of methamphetamine (ice), which carries a maximum penalty of life imprisonment. Our criminal defence lawyers negotiated guilty pleas to five charges, with three further offences taken into account. In the District Court of NSW, the judge rejected the Crown's case that our client was a principal of the drug syndicate and set a non-parole period of six years.

Bail · Break and enter

Urgent District Court bail on a specially aggravated break and enter charge

Bail granted before Christmas

Our client was charged with specially aggravated break and enter. It was alleged that he and others broke into a home and used a firearm to steal cash and valuables. Our lawyers made an urgent bail application to the District Court of NSW, which released him on bail immediately before Christmas.

Bail · Drug supply

Bail continued after a guilty plea to large commercial ice supply

Bail continued pending sentence

After our client pleaded guilty to supplying a large commercial quantity of methamphetamine (ice), the Director of Public Prosecutions applied to revoke his bail and have him remanded in custody under section 22B of the Bail Act 2013 (NSW) (opens in a new tab). Our criminal defence lawyers argued that full-time imprisonment was not inevitable, and the court continued bail pending sentence.

Drug supply · Sentencing

No conviction recorded for supplying an indictable quantity of drugs

Non-conviction order

Our client pleaded guilty to supplying an indictable quantity of prohibited drugs. After our lawyers presented a compelling case to the court, it made a non-conviction order, allowing our client to rebuild his life without a criminal conviction.

Affray · Defended charge

Not guilty of affray over a Bankstown junior rugby league brawl

Found not guilty

Our client was charged with affray after allegedly being involved in a brawl at a junior rugby league game in Bankstown. Despite the evidence presented against him, our lawyers successfully defended the charge, and the court found our client not guilty.

Bail · Kidnapping

Supreme Court bail on a specially aggravated kidnapping charge

Bail granted by the Supreme Court of NSW

Our client was charged with specially aggravated kidnapping over alleged significant involvement in a high-profile Sydney underworld kidnapping. Our lawyers identified critical weaknesses and gaps in the prosecution case and persuaded the Supreme Court of NSW to grant bail.

Drug supply · Charges withdrawn

Large commercial cocaine supply: all charges dropped

Bail granted · All charges withdrawn

After police stopped and searched our client's vehicle on a regional NSW highway, he was charged with supplying a large commercial quantity of cocaine. Our lawyers secured bail in the Local Court of NSW, then negotiated with the Director of Public Prosecutions and persuaded the prosecution to withdraw all charges.

GBH assault · Jury trial

Self-defence succeeds: jury finds client not guilty of GBH assault

Found not guilty after a two-week trial

Our client was charged with assault causing grievous bodily harm (GBH). The prosecution relied on multiple witnesses and evidence of the complainant's injuries. Our lawyers raised self-defence at a two-week trial in the District Court of NSW, and the jury found our client not guilty.

Common questions

Questions people ask.

  • Yes. Posting, commenting and messaging on social media all use a carriage service. The question is whether reasonable persons would regard the use as menacing, harassing or offensive in all the circumstances.

Useful next reads

WhatsApp