Skip to content

Refusing a breath test: the law and penalties.

Refusing a breath test, or not completing one as directed, is an offence in its own right. Refusing the breath analysis that follows an arrest carries the same maximum penalties and interlock order as high range drink-driving. This guide explains when police can test you, what must be proved, the penalties and the defences.

Partner-led advice · Fixed fee for every traffic service

Excellent · 119 Google reviews (as at November 2026)

Office hours Monday to Friday, 9am to 5pm. Urgent or after hours? Call 0404 791 111 or connect via WhatsApp.Can't talk now?

Portrait of Bash Elkheir

Bash Elkheir

Partner · Traffic law

View profile
Portrait of Bashir Elkheir

Bashir Elkheir

Senior Associate · Traffic law

View profile

Client feedback · Google reviews

A few words from our traffic law clients.

“Couldn’t have dreamt of a better outcome. My license was already disqualified for a year when I picked up a new charge and Bash worked his magic to not get any extended disqualification. Thanks so much to Bash and his team for their effort and help. Highly recommend Bash for any traffic matters.”
Mohamed FaragGoogle review excerpt · Traffic law
“I can’t thank Boushra and Bashir enough for everything they did for me. I had two very serious traffic matters, and thanks to Boushra’s knowledge, professionalism, and dedication, she achieved an incredible result that I honestly couldn’t …”
spookyGoogle review excerpt · Traffic law

The law, explained

General NSW information. Maximum penalties are not a prediction of your outcome. The charge, offence date and your record matter.

Part 1 of 5

The law

When can police require a breath test?

Under clause 3 of Schedule 3, police can require you to submit to a breath test if they have reasonable cause to believe that you are or were driving a motor vehicle on a road, that you are or were in the driving seat trying to put the vehicle in motion, or that you are or were the licence holder sitting next to a learner driver. Police do not need to suspect that you have been drinking.

Before the test, police can ask you to talk into a device that indicates whether alcohol is present in your breath.

What is the difference between a breath test and a breath analysis?

The breath test is the screening test at the roadside. If it indicates alcohol above the limit that applies to you, or if you refuse it, police can arrest you and take you to a police station or another place for a breath analysis (clause 4 of Schedule 3).

The breath analysis is carried out on a breath analysing instrument by an authorised officer. Afterwards, police must give you a signed written statement of the reading and the time the analysis was completed (clause 5 of Schedule 3).

What does clause 16 of Schedule 3 say?

Clause 16(1) makes it an offence to refuse or fail, when required by a police officer, to submit to a breath test or a breath analysis in accordance with the officer's directions. The same clause covers oral fluid tests and sobriety assessments.

Failing to submit in accordance with the directions covers more than saying no. Not blowing into the device as directed can be charged as a failure to submit.

Part 2 of 5

What must be proved and the maximum penalty

What must the prosecution prove for refusing a breath test?

The prosecution must prove each of these beyond reasonable doubt:

  • a police officer required you to submit to a breath test or breath analysis
  • the officer had the power to make the requirement, for example reasonable cause to believe you were driving
  • you refused, or failed to submit in accordance with the officer's directions

What are the maximum penalties?

OffenceFirst offenceSecond or subsequent offence
Refusing or failing a breath test (clause 16(1)(a))10 penalty units10 penalty units
Refusing or failing a breath analysis (clause 16(1)(b))30 penalty units and/or 18 months' imprisonment50 penalty units and/or 2 years' imprisonment

A penalty unit is $110. Refusing or failing a breath analysis is a major offence under the Road Transport Act 2013 (opens in a new tab), with the same maximum penalties as high range drink-driving.

What happens to my licence if I am convicted of refusing a breath analysis?

Refusing or failing a breath analysis is a mandatory interlock offence, so a conviction brings a mandatory interlock order. Under section 211 of the Road Transport Act 2013 (opens in a new tab):

  • for a first alcohol-related major offence, you are disqualified for at least 6 months and up to 9 months, then must hold an interlock licence for at least 24 months before you can hold an ordinary licence
  • for a second or subsequent alcohol-related major offence, the disqualification is 9 to 12 months, and the interlock period is at least 48 months

If the court deals with the charge without recording a conviction, under section 10 of the Crimes (Sentencing Procedure) Act 1999 (opens in a new tab), no disqualification or interlock order follows.

Part 3 of 5

Court, likely outcomes and your record

Which court deals with a breath test refusal?

The Local Court. You can plead not guilty and have a hearing, or plead guilty and be sentenced. The court looks at the circumstances of the refusal, your driving record and your personal circumstances.

What outcomes are possible?

Outcomes range from a dismissal or conditional release order without a conviction under section 10 of the Crimes (Sentencing Procedure) Act 1999 (opens in a new tab), to a fine and, for the breath analysis offence, a community-based order or imprisonment. A conviction for refusing a breath analysis brings the mandatory interlock order.

Can police take my vehicle?

If you were convicted of an alcohol-related major offence in the 5 years before, refusing or failing a breath analysis is a sanctionable offence (section 237 (opens in a new tab)). If you were the driver and a registered operator of the vehicle, police can seize and impound it or confiscate its number plates (section 239 (opens in a new tab)).

Part 4 of 5

Defences

Is there a defence if I could not blow into the device?

Yes, if it was for medical reasons. Under clause 16(2) of Schedule 3, it is a defence if you prove to the court's satisfaction that you were unable, on medical grounds, to submit to the test or analysis at the time. Evidence from your doctor is usually needed.

If you were physically unable to do the breath analysis, police can require a blood sample instead (clause 5A of Schedule 3). Refusing that sample is also an offence.

When can police not require a breath test?

Under clause 2 of Schedule 3, police cannot require a breath test or breath analysis:

  • if you have been admitted to hospital for treatment, unless the doctor in charge has been told and does not object
  • if it appears to the officer that it would be dangerous to your medical condition because of your injuries
  • more than 2 hours after the event that allowed police to require the test, such as your driving
  • at your home

A requirement made in one of these situations is not one police can lawfully make.

What other defences are available?

  • You were not driving, and police had no reasonable cause to believe you were, or that you were in one of the other situations that allow a test.
  • You did submit to the test or analysis in accordance with the officer's directions.
  • The evidence does not show that the officer actually required you to submit.

Part 5 of 5

First steps

What should I do if I am charged with refusing a breath test?

  • Write down the time and place you were stopped, when each test was requested and what was said.
  • If you have a condition that affects your breathing, get records from your doctor.
  • Note any witnesses, and ask your lawyer about obtaining police body-worn camera footage.
  • Get advice before your first court date. The plea affects whether the interlock order applies.

Common questions

Refusing a breath test: questions people ask.

  • Refusing or failing a breath analysis carries the same maximum penalties and the same interlock order as high range drink-driving, whatever your actual alcohol level was.

Useful next reads

WhatsApp