Challenging a will: capacity, undue influence and formal validity.
A validity challenge says a document should not be admitted to probate as the deceased's last will, for example because they lacked capacity or were coerced. It is different from a family provision claim, and it is best raised before probate is granted.
Office hours Monday to Friday, 9am to 5pm. Urgent or after hours? Call 0404 791 111 or connect via WhatsApp.Can't talk now?
Client feedback · Google reviews
A few words from our clients.
“Boushra is an excellent lawyer professional, knowledgeable, and very responsive. She took the time to explain everything clearly and made the entire process much less stressful. Very well spoken individual, I felt confident and supported throughout. Highly recommend her services.”
“The team was professional, supportive and easy to communicate with throughout the whole process. They made me feel comfortable, kept me informed, and handled everything efficiently. I’m very grateful for their help and would definitely recommend their services.”
The law, explained
General NSW information. Time limits are strict, and the outcome depends on the facts, the family and the size of the estate.
Part 1 of 4
The law
What makes a will formally valid?
Under section 6 of the Succession Act 2006 (opens in a new tab), a will must be in writing and signed by the will-maker, or by someone else in their presence and at their direction. The signature must be made or acknowledged in the presence of two or more witnesses present at the same time, and at least two of them must sign the will in the will-maker's presence. An attestation clause is not essential.
A gift to a person who witnessed the will is void, unless at least two other witnesses did not benefit, everyone who would benefit if the gift failed consents in writing, or the court is satisfied the will-maker knew and approved of the gift and made it freely (section 10 (opens in a new tab)).
Can an unsigned or informal document be a will?
Yes, in some cases. The court can treat a document that was not properly signed or witnessed as the deceased's will, or as an alteration or revocation of it, if satisfied that the person intended it to operate that way (section 8 (opens in a new tab)). Such documents can include drafts, notes and electronic records. The court can consider evidence of how the document was made and of the deceased's statements about their intentions.
What are the main grounds for challenging a will?
Lack of testamentary capacity: the will-maker must have understood that they were making a will and its effect, the nature and extent of their property, and the people who might have a claim on them, without a disorder of mind affecting their judgment. This test comes from the case of Banks v Goodfellow (1870).
Lack of knowledge and approval: the will-maker must have known and approved the contents. Suspicious circumstances, such as a beneficiary arranging the will, call for closer proof.
Undue influence and fraud: in this setting, undue influence means coercion that overbore the will-maker's free will, not persuasion or affection. Forgery and fraud need clear evidence.
Revocation and formal defects: the will may have been revoked, for example by a later will, by destruction or by marriage, or may not have been properly signed and witnessed.
When is a will revoked?
A will can be revoked by a later will, by a written declaration signed and witnessed like a will, or by the will-maker, or someone in their presence and at their direction, burning, tearing or otherwise destroying it with the intention of revoking it (section 11 (opens in a new tab)). Marriage generally revokes an earlier will, unless the will was made in contemplation of that marriage (section 12 (opens in a new tab)). Divorce generally revokes gifts to the former spouse and their appointment as executor, unless the will shows a contrary intention (section 13 (opens in a new tab)).
Part 2 of 4
Who can apply and the time limits
Who can challenge a will's validity?
A person whose interest depends on which will is valid can challenge it, such as a beneficiary or executor under an earlier will, or a person who would inherit if there were no valid will. Creditors and family provision claimants are not interested persons for this purpose, because their claims do not depend on which will is admitted to probate.
Is there a time limit?
There is no fixed deadline like the 12-month limit for family provision claims, but delay is risky. It is best to act before probate is granted and before the executor deals with the assets. After a grant, you can ask the court to revoke it, but this becomes harder and more costly once the estate has been distributed.
How does a caveat work?
A person claiming an interest in the estate can file a caveat, which stops a grant being made while it is in force. If the caveator knows of an applicant for a grant, the caveat must be served on them within 7 days (rule 66 of Part 78 of the Supreme Court Rules 1970 (opens in a new tab)). A caveat lapses after 6 months unless the court extends it (rule 69). The applicant can ask the court to end a caveat if the caveator has no proper interest.
A caveat can also require a will to be proved in solemn form, meaning in contested proceedings with evidence, rather than through the usual paperwork (rule 68).
Part 3 of 4
The process, costs and likely outcomes
How are validity disputes decided?
If the dispute is not resolved, the case is usually run on pleadings, starting with a statement of claim, and people who would be adversely affected must be given notice. The court hears evidence from witnesses such as the solicitor who prepared the will, the attesting witnesses, doctors and family members, and decides which document, if any, is the last valid will. If no will is valid, an earlier will or the intestacy rules apply.
Who pays the costs?
Costs are in the court's discretion. An unsuccessful party may have to pay the other side's costs, and contested hearings attract daily hearing fees. In some cases, such as where the deceased's own conduct or the state of their papers reasonably led to the dispute, costs may be ordered out of the estate. Early advice on the strength of the evidence helps avoid a costly dispute.
What outcomes are likely?
The court may admit the will to probate, admit an earlier will or an informal document, or find there is no valid will, so the estate passes under the intestacy rules. Many disputes settle with an agreed distribution. No outcome can be promised.
Part 4 of 4
First steps
What should you do first?
- Find out whether a probate application is planned: notices of intended applications are published on the NSW Online Registry.
- If you have a genuine interest, get advice quickly about filing a caveat before a grant is made.
- Collect evidence about the will-maker's health and circumstances when the will was made, such as medical records, and about who was involved in arranging it.
- Ask for the will file from the solicitor who prepared the will, which often records the instructions and observations about capacity.
- Consider whether you also have a family provision claim, and note its 12-month deadline.
What if you are the executor and the will is challenged?
Preserve the original will and the will-maker's papers, respond to any caveat, and do not distribute the estate while a genuine challenge is pending. Get advice on whether the will should be proved in solemn form, so that the result binds the people who were given notice.
Common questions
Challenging a will's validity: questions people ask.
Not on its own. The question is whether the will-maker had testamentary capacity when the will was made. Some people with a diagnosis can still make a valid will at a particular time; others cannot. Medical and other evidence from that time is key.
Yes, if it meets the formal requirements, or if the court is satisfied that the deceased intended the document to be their will.
Yes, by asking the court to revoke the grant, but it is harder and more costly once the estate has been dealt with. Act as early as possible.
A family provision claim, often called contesting a will, accepts that the will is valid but says it did not provide adequately for an eligible person. A validity challenge says the will itself should not be admitted to probate.
Generally yes, unless the will was made in contemplation of that marriage. Divorce generally cancels gifts to the former spouse and their appointment as executor, unless the will shows a contrary intention.
Useful next reads

