Contesting a will: family provision claims in NSW.
If someone close to you died without making adequate provision for you, you may be able to ask the Supreme Court of NSW for a share, or a larger share, of their estate. This is called a family provision claim, and it must generally be made within 12 months of the death.
Office hours Monday to Friday, 9am to 5pm. Urgent or after hours? Call 0404 791 111 or connect via WhatsApp.Can't talk now?
Client feedback · Google reviews
A few words from our clients.
“Had a great experience working with this firm. Everyone was professional and on top of things, and Boushra in particular was super helpful throughout the whole process. She made everything clear and easy to understand. Highly recommend!”
“I had a fantastic experience with Cordoba Legal. The team was professional and truly knowledgeable. They took the time to explain everything clearly and made sure I felt supported throughout the entire process.”
The law, explained
General NSW information. Time limits are strict, and the outcome depends on the facts, the family and the size of the estate.
Part 1 of 4
The law
What is a family provision claim?
A family provision claim asks the Supreme Court of NSW to order provision from a deceased person's estate for an eligible person. It does not say the will is invalid; it says the will, or the rules that apply when there is no will, did not make adequate provision. The law is in Chapter 3 of the Succession Act 2006 (opens in a new tab). If you believe the will itself is not valid, that is a different claim, explained in our guide to challenging a will's validity.
What does the court consider?
The court must be satisfied that the claimant is an eligible person and that, when it considers the claim, adequate provision for their proper maintenance, education or advancement in life has not been made by the will, the intestacy rules or both (section 59 (opens in a new tab)). A former spouse, a dependent grandchild or household member, or a person in a close personal relationship must also show factors that warrant the application.
In deciding whether to make an order and what it should be, the court can consider the matters in section 60(2) (opens in a new tab). They include the relationship with the deceased, any obligations the deceased had to the claimant, the size and nature of the estate, the claimant's financial needs and resources, their age and health, their contributions to the deceased's property or welfare, the deceased's wishes, the claimant's character and conduct, and the claims of others on the estate.
Can property outside the will be claimed?
Sometimes. The court can designate property as notional estate if it left the deceased's estate through a relevant property transaction (sections 75 and 76 (opens in a new tab)). Examples include a home held as joint tenants that passed to the surviving owner, a superannuation or life insurance payout, and a gift made before death.
Time limits apply to these transactions. For example, the court can reach a transaction made within 3 years before death with the intention of denying or limiting provision for the claimant, or one made within 1 year before death when the deceased's moral obligation to provide for the claimant was substantially greater than any obligation to enter into the transaction (section 80 (opens in a new tab)). So a claim can reach further than the will itself.
Part 2 of 4
Who can apply and the time limits
Who is an eligible person?
Under section 57 (opens in a new tab), the eligible persons are:
- the deceased's spouse at the time of death;
- a person living in a de facto relationship with the deceased at the time of death;
- a child of the deceased, including an adopted child;
- a former spouse;
- a person who was at any time wholly or partly dependent on the deceased, and who is a grandchild or was at that time or any other time a member of the deceased's household; and
- a person living in a close personal relationship with the deceased at the time of death.
Being eligible does not mean a claim will succeed. The court still has to find that adequate provision was not made.
What is the time limit?
A claim must be made within 12 months after the date of death (section 58(2) (opens in a new tab)). The court can allow a later claim if sufficient cause is shown, or if the parties to the proceedings consent. A claim is made on the day it is filed with the court (section 58(3) (opens in a new tab)), and you do not need to wait for probate.
An executor who distributes the estate at least 6 months after the death, after giving at least 30 days' notice of the intended distribution and without notice of any claim, is protected from liability to a later claimant (section 93 (opens in a new tab)). That is why you should tell the executor early, in writing, that you intend to make a claim.
Can the right to claim be given up?
Only with the court's approval. A release of the right to make a family provision claim has effect only if the court approves it, and approval can be sought before or after the death (section 95 (opens in a new tab)). An agreement not to claim, without that approval, does not stop a claim.
Part 3 of 4
The process, costs and likely outcomes
How does a claim proceed?
A claim is started in the Equity Division of the Supreme Court of NSW by summons with a supporting affidavit, and a filing fee is payable. The executor responds with evidence about the estate and the other people with claims on it.
Unless the court orders otherwise for special reasons, the claim must be referred to mediation before it is heard (section 98(2) (opens in a new tab)). If the parties agree, the court can make orders in the terms of their written agreement (section 98(3) (opens in a new tab)). If not, the claim goes to a hearing, where the court decides on the evidence about need, the estate and the competing claims.
Who pays the legal costs?
The court can order that the costs of the proceedings, including mediation, be paid out of the estate or notional estate as it thinks fit (section 99 (opens in a new tab)). Costs do not always come from the estate: a claimant who fails may have to pay their own costs and the estate's costs. Where an estate is modest, the court is concerned that costs do not swallow it, which is one reason early settlement is encouraged.
What outcomes are likely?
Outcomes vary widely with the size of the estate, the claimant's needs and the competing claims. The court can order a lump sum, a share of the estate or particular property, and decide which gifts bear the cost. Many claims settle at mediation. No outcome can be promised.
Part 4 of 4
First steps
What should you do first?
- Note the date of death and the 12-month deadline, and get advice well before it.
- Ask the executor, or the solicitor holding the will, for a copy of the will and details of the estate.
- Write down your relationship with the deceased, any support they gave you, and your current financial position and needs.
- Collect evidence of your income, assets, debts, health and housing.
- Tell the executor in writing that you intend to make a claim, so they do not distribute the estate.
What if you are the executor facing a claim?
An executor's role is to protect the estate and put the relevant evidence before the court, rather than to take sides between beneficiaries. Get advice before distributing an estate while a claim is possible, and keep the beneficiaries informed. We can advise executors on responding to a claim and on the notices that protect them.
Common questions
Contesting a will: questions people ask.
Not as a child of the deceased. A stepchild may be eligible as a person who was dependent on the deceased and a member of their household. Whether that applies depends on the facts.
No. A claim can be made whether or not probate or administration has been granted, and the 12-month time limit runs from the date of death.
Generally no. A caveat is for disputes about which will is valid, and the Supreme Court does not treat a family provision claimant as having an interest for that purpose. Instead, tell the executor about your intended claim and file it in time.
Adult children are eligible persons. Whether a claim succeeds depends on their financial needs, the size of the estate, their relationship with the parent and the competing claims.
A family provision claim can still be made if the rules that apply when there is no will do not make adequate provision for an eligible person.
Useful next reads

